• Home
  • Practice Areas
  • Gallery
  • Team
  • Contact
  • By: admin
  • Feb 9
  • Comments (0)

TRIAL WITHIN TRIAL: A CLOG IN THE WHEEK OF PROGRESS OF NIGERIAN CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM

OLUWASEUN A. ALAO ESQ.  LLB, BL, LLM (UNILAG)

Introduction

Over the years, the concept of trial within trial has been mystified and given a rather higher status than the main trial. However, it is pertinent to demystify that misconception for it is foolhardy to say that a tree’s branch is greater than or distinct from the tree. When the end is the dispensation of justice, unnecessary elevation of the trial within trial proceeding to the detriment of speedy and efficient justice may well be counterproductive. This paper takes a glossary look at trial-within-trial, the current procedure adopted and the need to re-invent the trial-within-trial procedure in order to make it a lubricant rather than a clog to the wheel of justice.

Trial Within Trial

Bob Osamor posits that a trial-within-trial is the public demonstration and testing of the case of the contending parties before a court. He stated further that the demonstration is by assertion and evidence and the testing by cross-examination and argument. For the purpose of this paper, we posit a simplistic definition of a criminal trial as the public demonstration and testing of the case for the parties to determine guilt or innocence of a person alleged to have committed a crime.

The Hon. Justice Sonia Akinbiyi opines that a trial-within-trial may be called for when the voluntariness of a confessional statement is challenged, that is, the confessional statement is alleged to have been obtained involuntarily. The learned Justice further stated that retraction or denial of confessional statement does not affect its admissibility and so there would not be need for trial-within-trial.

A trial within trial arises when confessional statement presented as evidence to prove defendant’s guilt before a court is challenged on the ground of involuntariness when making the statement. In other words, trial-within-trial is a procedural verification of confessional statement purported to have been obtained from a person charged with a crime intended by the prosecution to prove his guilt if and when admitted in evidence.

To determine voluntariness or involuntariness of a maker of such statement, the Evidence Actenjoins the court to abandon the main trial, conduct a mini trial in pursuit of what transpired at the material time of making the confessional statement.

Accordingly, by the provision of section 29 of the Evidence Act, the court is statutorily bound to disallow the admission of confessional statement in evidence if in the face of doubts raised by the court or defence establishing a prima facie case of oppression, duress or inducement contrary to the said section. The Supreme Court giving life to the letters of section 29 of the Act in Obidiozo & Ors.  v. The State stated thus:

” So, it can be confidently said on the authorities of R. v. Igwe and the Queen v. Eguabor {supra} that when an issue arises as to whether a confession was made voluntarily, a trial-within-trial must be adopted to determine the admissibility of the confession before it is ever admitted in evidence.”

Trial-Within-Trial Procedure

As the name implies, a trial within trial is to test the voluntariness or otherwise of a confessional statement of an accused goes through the same process of evidence as with a normal substantive trial. The burden of proving that the confessional statement was obtained voluntarily from the defendant rests with the prosecution. The Prosecution is to adduce evidence beyond reasonable doubt to satisfy the Court that the confessional statement was made by the Defendant and voluntarily. Any doubt raised from the entirety of evidence adduced by the Prosecution, ought as with criminal trial be resolved in favour of the Defendant.

After the evidence of the Prosecution, the Defendant is afforded an opportunity to adduce evidence to cast aspersion on the voluntariness of the confessional as with a normal substantive trial. At the end of the evidence, the Court then like judgment on substantive matter, delivers its ruling as to whether the confessional statement have been successfully proven by the prosecution to be voluntary, at which point it is admitted. Where the Prosecution has failed in its burden, then it is marked as “tendered and rejected” or “rejected”.

The Clog that Is the Procedure of Trial Within Trial

From the forgoing procedure summarily laid out, it appears that the procedure is fairly simple and straight forward in aid of justice, however, that is not usually the case. And herein lies the challenges and the clog that is the extant procedure of trial within trial. The Court which has heard the evidence in trial within trial is expected to render its decision before the main trial proceeds. The rationale is that the trial within trial proceeding is distinct from the main trial and evidence therefrom cannot be transplanted into the main trial and vice versa. The implication of this is far-reaching.

While the trial within trial is necessary, the clog therefrom is occasioned by the exercise of the right of appeal against ruling on same. It is within the right or prerogative of a party who is aggrieved by the decision of court whether interlocutory or final, to exercise its right to appeal the decision. More specifically, the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria allows appeal as of right or with leave of court from the High Court to the Court of Appeal. Similarly, provisions exist for appeal from lower courts to courts of record.

The law stipulates lesser period for appeal against interlocutory decisions compared to appeal against final decisions. The Court’s ruling in trial within trial has been held to be an interlocutory decision, thus any appeal therefrom will only amount to an interlocutory appeal and ought to be brought within the limited period of fourteen (14) days or otherwise only with leave of court and extension of time to do so. The implication is that, an aggrieved party cannot afford to delay the ventilation of his grievance on appeal, in its bid to wait for the final decision of the trial court on the substantive matter.

In the case of Atabo v. FRN it was held that the appellant having failed to bring his appeal against the ruling of the trial court the validity of the confessional statement has been sealed.

The following judicial position, unfortunately, ensures that parties immediately proceed to file an appeal against such ruling that is not in their favour. The resulting implication is that parties accordingly file for stay of proceedings, ensuring that the main trial does not proceed given the vital nature of the voluntariness of a confessional statement. Consequently, the trial is stalled until parties go the full haul of appeal process up to the apex court.

As we had earlier noted, a cardinal necessity for justice is that it not be unduly delayed. When criminal trials are stalled due to the mechanism/procedure of the Court, it is even more unfortunate. Most of the defendants facing these trials are placed in custody during the full haul of the trial process and many also are stuck in custody for the sheer reason that they could not meet the bail conditions.

With the already slow wheel of justice and especially the criminal justice system, it is pertinent for a more efficient procedure to be adopted to eliminate any further delay to the judicial process and decongest the dockets of the Courts. We note that decisions of court have been that a Court cannot deliver a ruling on trial within trial with the judgment on the substantive matter.It is argued that the trial within trial is a distinct process and should not be lumped together with the main trial. However, it is our position that carrying out the trial within trial procedure simultaneously with the main trial, does not necessarily jeopardise its distinctness, as same can still be maintained by the Court while also issuing distinct ruling on the substantive matter. A proper compartmentalization of the evidence and ensuring that there is no overlap or transplantation can ensure the efficiency as well as the distinct nature of both proceedings.

It is necessary for the entire trial process including the trial within trial to be handled simultaneously with any ruling or judgment rendered at the same time, ensuring that parties exercise their right of appeal while not unduly delaying the criminal justice process before the Courts. This more efficient procedure can be adopted without tainting the distinction that exists between the trial within trial and the main trial.

The alternative to conducting the two separate proceedings (trial within trial and main trial) simultaneously is requiring parties who are aggrieved with the ruling to reserve their appeal until the final judgment at the trial court in order to appeal both ruling and judgment together. This may not be a favoured option however, as in such scenario, the aggrieved party is required to seek leave of court and extension of time, given that the ruling in trial within trial is an interlocutory decision and/or had been presented out of the prescribed period.

Conclusion and Recommendations

Trial-within-trial is a mini trial conducted at the instance of the court or defence to determine the voluntariness or otherwise of a confessional statement sought to be tendered by the prosecution to determine its admissibility. It is without doubt, that the rationale for the mechanism is noble, however, the procedure to its conduct has proven to be a spanner thrown into the wheel of justice. This is borne from the exercise of a party’s right to appeal the trial court’s ruling in trial within trial. The interlocutory appeal process sometimes ensures that the main trial/proceedings at the trial court is stalled as parties go the full haul of appealing the ruling in trial within trial.

It is our recommendation therefore that;

1. Necessary amendments be made to the Constitution, Administration of Criminal Justice Act/laws and other extant laws and rules on criminal procedure such that the conduct of the trial within trial should be simultaneous with the conduct of the main trial while maintaining the distinctive nature of both proceedings. The result will be that the ruling on both trial within trial and the substantive matter are delivered at the same time. That way, parties’ rights to appeal the ruling in trial within trial is not made to clog the wheel of the criminal justice system.
2. As a less palatable alternative to our first recommendation above, parties should be encouraged by the Courts (especially appellate courts) via its enabling laws, rules and practice directions, to appeal against the ruling in trial within trial together with the final decision, as opposed to doing so separately.

BIBLIOGRAPHY

1. THE HOLY BIBLE
2. 1999 CONSTITUTION OF THE FEDERAL REPUBLIC OF NIGERIA
3. EVIDENCE ACT, 2011
4. ADMINISTRATION OF CRIMINAL JUSTICE ACT, 2015
5. ADMINISTRATION OF CRIMINAL JUSTICE LAW OF LAGOS STATE
6. CRIMINAL LITIGATION IN NIGERIA – HON. JUSTICE SONIA AKINBIYI
7. FUNDAMENTALS OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURE LAW IN NIGERIA – BOB OSAMOR
8. LAW AND PRACTICE OF EXTRA-JUDICIAL AND CONFESSIONAL STATEMENTS: THE CASENOTES – UGOCHUKWU MIKE MGBEAHURU

  • Share:

Add your Comment

Recent Posts

  • TRIAL WITHIN TRIAL: A CLOG IN THE WHEEK OF PROGRESS OF NIGERIAN CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM

Search

Recent Posts

  • TRIAL WITHIN TRIAL: A CLOG IN THE WHEEK OF PROGRESS OF NIGERIAN CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM 09 Feb 2026

© Copyright 2026 | O.A Alao Legal Practice | All right reserved.